Author:         Mathieu Lafon <mlafon@gmail.com>
State:          Draft
Type:           Project
Created:        05-May-2017
Tcl-Version:    8.7
Vote:		Done
Post-History:
Tcl-Branch:     info-linkedname
Vote-Summary:   Rejected 2/2/3
Votes-For:      DKF, JN
Votes-Against:  KBK, DGP
Votes-Present:  BG, FV, SL
Vote-Comments:  feature provides insufficient information to be useful,
                and cannot work in way suitable to solve rationale; please
                rethink it (talk to TCT to help resolve)

Abstract

This TIP proposes to improve link variable introspection by providing a new info linkedname command.

Rationale

This TIP is related to discussions about [457] and the -upvar extended argument specifier. Adding an intropsection command to get the name of the variable linked to is more Tcl-ish than automatically adding a local variable with the linked name. The proposed command is not restricted to [457] usage as this can also be used for a link variable created by other means, using the upvar command for example.

Specification of the Proposed Change

There should be a new subcommand of info created with the following syntax:

info linkedname varname

The varname should be the name of a variable that has been linked to another variable (e.g., with upvar, global, variable or namespace upvar), and the result of the command will be the name of the variable linked to.

Reference Implementation

The reference implementation is available in the info-linkedname branch.

The code is licensed under the BSD license.

Implementation Notes

Depending on the linked variable, the name is found using different methods:

The name of a variable present in a hash table (globals, local variables created at runtime, ...) is retrieved using the hash key;
The name of an array element is built using the name of the array and the index name, retrieved using the hash key. A new field is added to the TclVarHashTable sructure to access the related array variable from the array element;
The name of a compiled local variable is searched in current or upper call frames.

Copyright